Sandwich Panel Long Beam and Short Beam Tests

Click here to access pdf versions of the latest blog posts…

In the aircraft cabin interiors industry, sandwich panel long beam and short beam tests are commonly used to determine sandwich panel flexure (or bending) and core shear allowable stress values. These allowable stress values are influenced by whether the panel test coupon long axis is aligned with the core ribbon (‘L’) direction or the weaker core cell flats (‘W’) direction. To learn more about this concept, check out this post: Sandwich Panel Flexure and Core Shear. As a follow up, in this post we will study the test methods, the test set ups and other interesting details. The methods are discussed in a lot more detail in ASTM-C393 (core shear) and ASTM-D7249 (flexure) specification documents. Are you ready? I thought so. Let us dig in then…

Sandwich Panel Long Beam and Short Beam Tests – Flexure Allowable Stress:

The honeycomb sandwich panel flexure or bending allowable stress is calculated using ‘long beam’ bending tests. Various long beam test methods are used such as three point (two bottom side end supports and one top side middle loading point), four point (two bottom side end supports and two top side upper loading points) etc. The reason is that some methods are more suitable to inducing failure in certain panel types. In this section we will study the four point quarter span (non-standard) long beam test set up. Many different coupons are tested and finally A-Basis and B-Basis statistical values are calculated from the test results.

Long Beam Bending
Figure 2: Four Point Quarter Span (non-standard) Long Beam Bending Test Set Up

We can see in the figure above, the panel is supported by the green round supports on the bottom. It is loaded by the green round load points on top. The supports and load points are round to allow free rotation of the panel as it is loaded.

S = The total span of the supports [in a standard configuration this value would be 22.0″]

S/4 = The distance of the load points from the supports

L = Distance between the load points [in a standard configuration this value would be 4.0″]

d = Nominal test coupon thickness

b = Nominal test coupon width

t = nominal test coupon facing or skin thickness

From classical beam theory, the figure below illustrates the shear force and bending moment diagrams on this test coupon.

Finite Element Analysis Online Course

Finite Element Analysis CourseBronze Level Course!

Long_Beam_SFD_BMD
Figure 3: Long Beam Test Shear Force and Bending Moment Diagrams

The load 'P' is increased on this test coupon until failure occurs. Assume this load is Pmax.

Hence Maximum Bending Moment M = (Pmax/2)*S/4 in-lb = Pmax*S/8 in-lb

Typical failure mode is skin buckling failure on the top side near the middle of the coupon. From the maximum test load, the ultimate flexure or bending stress is calculated using the following formula:

Fult_b = M / {(d-t)*t*b} psi

Sandwich Panel Long Beam and Short Beam Tests - Core Shear Allowable Stress:

The core shear test set up is similar to the long beam test set up. The difference is that the distance S is much smaller at about 6.0", which makes sense from a classical beam theory stand point. For short stubby beams, shear deflection is the most significant component as opposed to deflection due to bending for long beams. Typical failure mode is core crush failure under the load points. The core shear stress is calculated using the following formula:

Fult_s = Pmax / {2*(d-t)*b} psi

Related to Sandwich Panel Long Beam and Short Beam Tests, here is a cool video that goes into the manufacturing process of composite sandwich panels:

So there you have it. I Hope you learnt something new today about Sandwich Panel Long Beam and Short Beam Tests. Comments and questions are highly encouraged at the bottom of the post. If you have any suggestions to improve technical details on Sandwich Panel Long Beam and Short Beam Tests, or any other posts, comment below to let me know....

Thank you.

Want to get instant updates on the latest posts like this one and a free Ebook? 

Click Here...

Like this post? Why not share the love...


Surya Batchu
Surya Batchu

Surya Batchu is the founder of Stress Ebook LLC. A senior stress engineer specializing in aerospace stress analysis and finite element analysis, Surya has close to a decade and a half of real world industry experience. He shares his expertise with you on this blog and the website via paid courses, so you can benefit from it and get ahead in your own career.